Race, Nation, Class: Ambiguous Identitiesby Published 17 Dec 1991
|Race, Nation, Class: Ambiguous Identities.pdf|
Forty years after the defeat of Nazism, and twenty years after the great wave of decolonization, how is it that racism remains a growing phenomenon? What are the special characteristics of contemporary racism? How can it be related to class divisions and to the contradictions of the nation-state? And how far, in turn, does racism today compel us to rethink the relationship between class struggles and nationalism?
This book attempts to answer these fundamental questions through a remarkable dialogue between the French philosopher Etienne Balibar and the American historian and sociologist Immanuel Wallerstein. Each brings to the debate the fruits of over two decades of analytical work, greatly inspired, respectively, by Louis Althusser and Fernand Braudel.
Both authors challenge the commonly held notion of racism as a continuation of, or throwback to, the xenophobias of past societies and communities. They analyse it instead as a social relation indissolubly tied to present social structures—the nation-state, the division of labour, and the division between core and periphery—which are themselves constantly being reconstructed. Despite their productive disagreements, Balibar and Wallerstein both emphasize the modernity of racism and the need to understand its relation to contemporary capitalism and class struggle. Above all, their dialogue reveals the forms of present and future social conflict, in a world where the crisis of the nation-state is accompanied by an alarming rise of nationalism and chauvinism.
Race, Nation, Class: Ambiguous Identities Reviews
Not very interesting or compelling. Suffers from unclear ontology of nation/ethnicity/race. Balibar's popular piece for example ("The Nation Form: Theory and History") only offers some very basic constructivist takes on 20th century European ethnogenesis as a result.
Most worthwhile part (concerned with nationalism) is Wallerstein's "The Construction of Peoplehood", which includes a long and informative discussion on political boundaries in apartheid-era South Africa.
Bu tip kitapları okumak güç ister,wallerstein bu durumu daha da zorlaştırmış ve inanın ki wallerstein sizi okumadan soğutup kitaptan uzaklaştırıyor;ama etienne balibar'ın üslubu,onun kolay okunulabilirliği sizi kitaba yeniden çekiyor.İki yazarın da olaylara,olgulara ilginç bir perspektiften bakması kitabın etkileyici olmasını sağlıyor.Politikaya ilgili olanlar bu kitabı kaçırmamalı.
i have learned nothing because i have just started to read.
Balibar as usual is excellent. Can't say the same for Wallerstein